There is a fascinating ambivalence about dreams and dreaming
in Buddhist tradition. On the one hand, Buddhism begins with a conception dream
of the Buddha’s mother, Queen Maya, in which a numinous white elephant enters
her body and is then born through her. On the other hand, ordinary dreams are
often dismissed as the product of confusion and the work of the “three poisons”
of desire, hatred and fear.
The dreamworld
is a realm of illusion – but so is everything in the experience of a human who
has not attained spiritual liberation. The great Tibetan lama Milarepa counsels
his disciples that dreams are of no importance – and then instructs them to pay
close attention to their dreams and tell them to him in the morning; his favorite
pupil, Gambopa, brings a powerful prophetic dream that previews the spread of
Buddhism in Tibet.
In Tibet,
the Buddhist ambivalence about dreams is accompanied by a dynamic process of
conflict and engagement over many centuries with indigenous shamans known as
“heroes” and “invokers”. Dreaming is a basic mode of shamanic operations, a
means of travel by which shamans interact with the powers of the deeper world
and guide souls of the living and the dead. As mediators for the community,
shamans meet and negotiate with the conscious, spiritual aspects of all life,
including the Earth itself. By contrast, the first Buddhist rulers of Tibet
planted twelve pagodas at strategic points on the body of the land, to “nail”
and hold in subjugation the Earth Mother they characterized as a “demoness”.
In an excellent and
very readable scholarly study, Angela Sumegi explores the creative tension
between Tibetan Buddhism and shamanic dreaming. In Dreamworlds of Shamanism and Tibetan Buddhism, Sumegi demonstrates
how, while retaining its philosophy of transcendence, Buddhism in Tibet
has adopted many of the characteristic techniques of shamanic dreamers, healers
and diviners. She explains that she was drawn to this theme by records of the
highly shamanic visionary experiences of the Fifth Dalai Lama who once, during
a serious illness, invoked a fierce deity who projected a scorpion inside his
body that proceeded to devour his organs until he seemed to burst into flame;
his illness then passed.
I interviewed Angela Sumegi on my “Way of the Dreamer” radio show in 2010, when her book came out. There was a little
magic in play that day. I rose on the
morning of the interview with two fragments from the hypnopompic zone, the
intermediate state between sleep and full waking. In a vivid dream scene, I
watched Central Asian riders gallop across a great plain where everything was
verdant green. Above them, thunderheads came rolling across the sky. When I
looked at the lightning, I suddenly saw it as the riders did – as a fiery god,
resplendent in red garments, hurling thunderbolts as he rode the sky on a great
charger.
When the scene
receded, a word came into my mind with quiet insistence: Kalachakra.
I thought these
scraps from my dreamlife might be a rehearsal for my interview. Prior to
recording the radio show, I took Angela’s book along to a conference at a
medical center, where I was kept waiting for much longer than expected. This
gave me a chance to re-read sections of her book, including a discussion of the
concept of tendrel to which I’ll turn
in a moment. The person who cleared the logjam at the doctors’ office was a
very efficient and pleasant Jamaican. His origin interested me, because I had
noticed that Angela Sumegi was born in Jamaica, though she migrated to Canada
many years ago and now taught at Carleton
University in Ottawa. I had not met
anyone from Jamaica
for many years. Now, in the space of a few minutes, I was going from one
Jamaican to another.
This seemed like
a meaningful coincidence. It also felt auspicious, in relation to the
interview, since the first Jamaican had played such a helpful role. Might this
be an example of the workings of what Tibetan Buddhists call tendrel?
I put the
question to Angela Sumegi on the air. She reminded me that the word tendrel is a contraction of a longer
phrase referring to the Buddhist doctrine of “dependent origination”, according
to which all phenomena arise “dependent on causes and conditions”. It is also
used to mean “sign” or “omen”. So the word applies both to the practice of
reading signs in coincidence, natural phenomena, divination kits and dreams -
and to a deep philosophy of hidden causes. Tibetan paintings show the
twelvefold manifestation of the principle of dependent origination around the
Wheel of Life: old age and death arise from birth, etc., etc. As Sumegi
explains in her book: “The principle that all phenomena arise interconnectedly
and interdependently applies without exception to every existent, linking them
throughout time and space; what appears to be a random or chance occurrence can
be analyzed in terms of its connections.”
We agreed that my Jamaican
sequence might be an example of tendrel at work in the divinatory
sense of an omen that felt promising. It also hinted at hidden patterns of
causation and connection.
We were already deep into the
practice of dreaming. In dreaming cultures, dreams are not isolated from
“signs” in the way of Western dream analysis. You read signs in dreams; you
also look for dreamlike symbols in the midst of everyday life.
I told Angela the fragments from
my dreams and asked her what the Tibetan mind would make of these. She went to
the right place (from my point of view) immediately, by telling me that
Tibetans would want to know my feelings around the dreams. I am firmly
convinced that the first thing we need to know about a dream is how the dreamer
felt about it, on first waking. My
feelings around the dream scene of the horseman on the verdant plain were of
excitement and driving energy, which Angela proceeded to confirm in commenting
on the positive energy she felt in the horses and the lush green of the
landscape.
What about that word, Kalachakra?
“It’s the great Wheel of Time,”
Angela explained, “and the most complex and profound of the approaches to
Tantra. It is also the name of a ritual His Holiness the Dalai Lama conducts
frequently.”
As we discussed the Kalachakra
ceremony, we noticed that it features dreaming. Monks hand out sheaves of kusha grass – long blades to place under
the mattress, shorter ones to tuck under the pillow. Grass to dream on, and to
invoke only good dream experiences.
Angela suggested that the way the
word “Kalachakra” had come to me might be an example of what Tibetan Buddhists
call a dream of “permission”: an invitation to proceed to a deeper connection
with a practice or a deity.
By now, I was enjoying our
conversation hugely. I knew already the depth of Angela’s research, including
the years she has spent in India
studying with Tibetan religious communities and learning the languages. She now
confirmed her credentials in the way that dreamers instantly recognize, by
sharing a night vision from her childhood in Jamaica in which a huge figure
with three eyes and fearsome weapons entered her space. She was able to
identify this entity many years later, as she embarked on Tibetan studies and
first saw images of the deity known as Mahakala (the “Great Black One”).
Picture: 12th century Tibetan Mahakala in Rubin Museum of Art